What are the Best Anna Maria Island Ice Cream Shops?

Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem on Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its stunning beaches, charming small-town vibe, and vibrant food scene. One of the best ways to cool off and indulge in a sweet treat during your stay in an Anna Maria Island vacation rental is to visit one of the many ice cream shops scattered throughout the island. From classic flavors to unique creations, there’s something for everyone.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the top ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island that are must-visit spots during your stay in one of our vacation rentals.

So whether you’re a local or a visitor, get ready to grab a scoop and enjoy the best ice cream Anna Maria Island offers.

Coquina Beach Café

If you’re looking for a place to satisfy your sweet tooth and take in the stunning scenery of Anna Maria Island, then Coquina Beach Café is the perfect spot for you. This beachside café is just steps from the ocean, offering guests breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico while they enjoy their meals. 

In addition to serving up a variety of breakfast and lunch options, Coquina Beach Café also offers Edy’s Ice Cream and Sno Cones, making it a go-to destination for those craving some refreshing Anna Maria Island ice cream treats. And if you’re looking for something a little stronger, stop by their Tiki Bar for beer, wine, or frozen drinks. 

Coquina Beach Café is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a delicious treat with its expansive patio, beachside tables, and relaxed atmosphere. So make sure to add it to your list of must-visit Anna Maria Island ice cream shops during your vacation on this beautiful island.

Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream 

If you’re craving some delicious, homemade Anna Maria Island ice cream, then Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream is worth checking out. This beloved ice cream shop has been a staple in the Cortez area for over three decades, serving high-quality frozen treats that satisfy any sweet tooth.

Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream offers many options, including soft serve, pints and quarts, banana splits, ice cream cones, milkshakes, sundaes, and floats. With over 300 flavors created since the shop’s founding, there’s truly something for everyone to enjoy.

One thing that sets Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream apart is its commitment to quality and freshness. Each batch of ice cream is handmade in small five-gallon quantities to ensure distinct taste and freshness. Owner and ice cream aficionado Rob Alderson prepares the finest gourmet ice cream several days each week, always working to improve and create new flavors for customers.

When you’re vacationing on Anna Maria Island, Tyler’s Gourmet Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for any ice cream lover. So stop by, grab a scoop (or two!), and taste the difference that over three decades of experience and passion for ice cream can make.

Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery

For those seeking a taste of authentic Italian gelato and baked goods on Anna Maria Island, look no further than the Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery. This family-owned creamery and bakery offer a wide variety of handmade gelato, sorbets, pastries, desserts, truffles, and locally roasted gourmet coffee specialties.

Located at the heart of Anna Maria Island, this creamery and bakery is the perfect place to relax and enjoy the ultimate Gulfside Hideaway experience. Using all-natural ingredients from fresh fruits to local dairy, their gelato is made on-site and served at a warmer temperature than standard ice cream, giving it a silky and soft texture with less fat.

Visitors can try any favorite flavors for free, including mint chip, AMI caramel, and eight different chocolate-based flavors. Dairy-free sorbetto and customized sundaes are also available, and children will love the topping and dipping station. In addition to its gelato, the creamery offers a wide range of baked goods, including danishes, croissants, cakes, and desserts.

Small Town Creamery 

If you’re looking for an award-winning ice cream experience on Anna Maria Island, Small Town Creamery is the place to be. With five consecutive years of blue ribbon wins nationwide, their ice cream is a must-try for any dessert lover. Visiting Small Town Creamery is one of many popular things to do on Anna Maria Island with kids.

But Small Town Creamery is more than just ice cream. In addition to their delicious homemade ice cream, they offer a variety of treats, including fudge, nuts, cool beads, candy, and locally roasted coffee. 

Two Scoops

Two Scoops is the perfect place to indulge in homemade ice cream for those looking for a sweet treat on Anna Maria Island. With 32 flavors, this family-owned ice cream parlor and coffee café has been a favorite among locals and visitors since it opened in 2007.

Located in Bayview Plaza at the North End of Anna Maria Island, Two Scoops is known for its delicious ice cream and welcoming atmosphere. Customers are greeted with smiles from the friendly staff and the fun-loving atmosphere of the parlor.

In addition to its 32 flavors of ice cream, Two Scoops also offers a variety of toppings and mix-ins to make your dessert even more decadent. And for those looking for something other than ice cream, they have a selection of coffee and other beverages.

The success of Two Scoops is evident in their multiple TripAdvisor Certificates of Excellence, which they have received for eight consecutive years. It’s no wonder customers keep returning to this family-friendly spot where ice cream and good times are always on the menu.

Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff

Holy Cow Ice Cream is a family-owned shop that has been serving homemade ice cream since 2009. With 36 delicious flavors, including soft serve, almond milk, and sugar-free options, there is something for everyone at Holy Cow. The ice cream is made from locally sourced ingredients using the latest technology to ensure the best quality. 

Holy Cow also offers vegan and sugar-free options for those with dietary restrictions, including Mini Melts. At Holy Cow, customers are treated like family and can enjoy a milkshake, malt, or ice cream cone while receiving great service.

Your Anna Maria Island Vacation 

Looking for a tropical paradise to escape to for your next vacation? Look no further than Anna Maria Island, located on the Gulf Coast near Sarasota, Florida. With its pristine white sand beaches, turquoise waters, and abundant activities and attractions, Anna Maria Island is the perfect destination for a memorable vacation. And what better way to experience the island than by staying in one of our Anna Maria Island rentals? Island Vacation Properties is dedicated to providing our guests with the ultimate vacation experience. 

Whether planning a romantic getaway for two or a family vacation with the kids, our vacation rentals can accommodate your needs. Each rental has a kitchen, high-speed wireless internet, and convenient BBQ areas. Plus, our rentals are near popular things to do on Anna Maria Island, ensuring you’re never far from the action.

So, what are you waiting for? Book your Anna Maria Island vacation rental today and experience the vacation of a lifetime. Our team is here to help you plan your perfect getaway, so don’t hesitate to contact us with any questions. We look forward to welcoming you to Anna Maria Island!